HomeNYC EventsNYC ThanksgivingThanksgiving Day Dinner at Croton Reservoir Tavern

Thanksgiving Day Dinner at Croton Reservoir Tavern

We hope you’ll join us for Thanksgiving Dinner this year. We’ll be roasting our turkeys all day, so you are assured to be served the freshest and hottest meal around. Croton Reservoir Tavern is located only steps away from The Macys’ Thanksgiving Day Parade which runs from approximately 9am – noon and travels down 6th Avenue.

We are located 2 blocks from the heart of Times Square, ½ a block from Broadway and centrally located near all midtown transportation.

Available seatings are 12, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7 and 8pm
Please visit our website www.crotonnyc.com or call 212-997-6835 to make a reservation.

We are able to accommodate and welcome large groups.

2023 Thanksgiving Pre Fixe Menu

  • $65 per person (Excluding Tax and Gratuity)
  • Seating starts @ 11:30am
  • Serving a classic American three course Thanksgiving meal, curated by our renowned Chef Director William Lustburg. William has been a staple in the restaurant industry for the last 20 years. He is well known from his time at The Waldorf, Chopped, and Hell’s Kitchens.

2022 Thanksgiving Pre Fixe Menu

$65 Adult,
$25 Children (Excluding Tax and Gratuity)

20% Gratuity placed on all parties

We will be open from 12pm – 9pm on Thanksgiving, Thursday, November 24th, and reservations are required.

2021 Thanksgiving Pre Fixe Menu

$60 Adult,
$25 Children (Excluding Tax and Gratuity)

20% Gratuity placed on all parties

Please visit our website crotonnyc.com or call 212-997-6835 to make a reservation and make sure to tell us the NYC Insider Guide sent you!

Croton Reservoir Tavern Thanksgiving Dinner Menu

2019 Thanksgiving Pre Fixe Menu

$60 Adult,
$30 Children (Excluding Tax and Gratuity)

The restaurant’s 2019 three-course $60* Thanksgiving Day dinner’s menu choices include Butternut Squash Soup, Oven Roasted Turkey with all the fixings, Grilled Salmon, Pumpkin Ravioli and Pumpkin Pie for dessert.  Croton’s two-course $30* Kids Menu (for kids under 12 years of age) includes a choice of a Traditional Turkey Dinner, Chicken Fingers or Macaroni & Cheese, chocolate chip cookie for dessert and unlimited soft drinks. 

Prior Years Menus:


Butternut Squash Soup with orange crème fraiche

– or –

Mixed Greens Salad with tomatoes, carrots, cucumber, croutons and balsamic vinaigrette


Fresh Oven Roasted Turkey
Roasted Turkey breast, gravy, garlic mash, sausage stuffing,
seasonal vegetables, and cranberry compote

– or –

Beef Short Rib
Braised beef short rib, celery root puree,
roasted potatoes, seasonal vegetables and beef demi glaze

– or –

Grilled Salmon
Fresh grilled salmon served with roasted squash couscous
and a cucumber, tomato and spinach salad with basil vinaigrette

– or-
Pumpkin Ravioli
Pumpkin ravioli tossed with pine nuts and brown butter
garnished with sage, parmesan cheese and balsamic reduction


Pumpkin Pie with Spiced Whipped Cream

Thanksgiving Day Dinner At Croton Reservoir Tavern

About Croton Reservoir Tavern

Croton Reservoir Tavern Times Square

Croton Reservoir Tavern is an owner-operated Midtown Manhattan Tavern serving modern American cuisine and NYC’s most popular drinks prepared to the highest of standards and served with relaxed charm and cheerful attentive service. Come visit us for a comfortable and casual atmosphere, vibrant social scene, quality dining or special event hosting. Croton Reservoir Tavern is located steps away from Times Square, Broadway, Bryant Park and midtown Manhattan transportation.

  • crotonnyc.com
  • 108 W 40th St (btw 6th & Broadway)
  • https://www.facebook.com/CrotonReservoir

More: Thanksgiving Dinner in NYC


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Site Sponsors

Recent Posts

US Tennis Open Arthur Ashe Seating Chart

US Open Tickets On Sale June 3rd

US Open Tickets for individual sessions go on sale to the public the first week in June, usually the day after Roland Garros finals....

July 4th in New York City Fireworks

NYC Fireworks Boat Cruises, Hotels, Yankees+ July 4th in New York City is amazing! The weather is almost always wonderful and our 4th of July...
Best US Tennis Open Hotels

Best US Tennis Open Hotels

Winter in NYC

Radio City Christmas Spectacular with Rockettes

The Radio City Christmas Spectacular is a hit every year, with tickets selling like crazy. Audiences of all ages will appreciate the singing, dancing,...
Christmas in New York City

Christmas in New York City